Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit | collyw's commentslogin

"Privacy concerns", i.e it returns results that they don't want you seeing.


Are the models really getting better and better? They tell us they are but I haven't noticed much difference in the last year or two.


It goes a bit up and down, compared to two years ago, in my feeling, both anthropic and open ai coding models have made massive jumps. In between big releases I do feel the quality of the models varies over time. 2 years ago I got annoyed with the models being crappy autocompletes, right now I'm just managing them more rather than coding myself


It's closed source, how would you know?


I used to work there - but I was talking about their reputation, not the actual quality of their code.


Yet they managed to get a fake disease into them.


I has tennis elbow a while ago. Was going to see the doctor but there was a wait. Looked up natural antiinflamatories. Turmeric came up. Did turmeric and black pepper milkshakes for a week and it fixed it.


I hear you. The problem is... It might have just gotten better by itself. Hard to know.


Maybe.


Or the turmeric did nothing and it fixed itself the way the vast majority of injuries heal.


Turmeric always does something.

Whether it’s enough to make a difference in your case depends.


The problem is that this is either unsupported by evidence or a meaninglessly shallow claim. After all, almost every herbal remedy does something, but it doesn't mean it's actually therapeutic for some given condition.


The problem is, you’re out of date regarding the recent efforts put into studying and documenting long-known herbs.

Curcumin is a polyphenol that operates at the molecular level to disrupt multiple inflammatory cascades. It achieves this by simultaneously blocking the transcription of inflammatory genes and interrupting the enzymes responsible for generating pain and swelling.

https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC10111629/

I’ve got a couple other examples I’ve come across recently that I can additionally share.


That paper is co-authored by Bharat B. Aggarwal, who has been found to produce fraudulent research [1], and many of whose papers have been retracted. This is the guy mentioned in the New Scientist article!

Curcumin has been extensively studied, and a common observation is that it is fantastically bioactive in vitro, but tends to have zero meaningful properties when introduced into the biology of a real human being. Researchers have categorized it as an IMPS (invalid metabolic panacea), i.e. a drug whose chemical properties are an illusion, and has ended up becoming a "black hole" for scientific funding [2] [3].

The part about how it "disrupts multiple inflammatory cascades" and so on sounds terrific until you realize these are behaviours observed in vitro. The fact is that curcumin is unstable and highly reactive, so it gets torn apart and neutralized early during digestion, leading to insanely low bioavailability. Tons of compounds are anti-inflammatory in vitro. Very few actually are in the human body.

[1] https://reeserichardson.blog/2024/01/30/the-king-of-curcumin...

[2] https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/26505758/

[3] https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/28074653/


Are you sure that means this particular paper is bad?

Fair point, though. Good news, lots of others:

https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC9881416/#S9

https://lpi.oregonstate.edu/mic/dietary-factors/phytochemica...

Also curious how many of those detracting have observed the use of capsules,

or the difference in a person not making proper gut acids / liver function.


One problem is: a tennis elbow does not really involve inflammation... Look it up.


I did, it says it sometimes involves inflammation, but it was self diagnosed anyway.Either way I drank turmeric milkshakes and it went away. Maybe by itself, maybe because of the turmeric.


Good thing it did, I've been struggling with it for 9 months now. I'm seeing a new specialist next week.


How long had the problem persisted before you considered going to the doctor?


Probably a bit over a week. Twinged after kayaking at the weekend. Got worse the following weekend and wasn't going away.


Look up grid computing. It never really took off.


really? I mean there's this little book company called Amazon who will let you use their interweb computers for a few dollars per hour. They'll sell you coffee as well.


"But if not, then it raises the question of why do we even have this "extra" consciousness"

Keep chipping away Dawkins, you might arrive at God eventually.


Try being rude to them, they will usually respond back politely.


Someone that has recently dies has pretty much the same biology as when they were alive. The conciseness is the main difference, I would say.


Indeed, doing a first aid course we were pointed out that sleeping is different from being unconscious. You can wake someone from sleep pretty quickly. You can't bring an unconscious person back in the same way.


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: