Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

"Your business has millions of customers and no single customer can do so many actions so quickly that the individual could create a hot key. Under this key you are storing around 2KB of data. ... Potentially getting 1–5 requests per second for a given second but certainly not a sustained load of that. ... This will not work at scale in DynamoDb."

What? Why? Suppose that's 5 million customers, you will only have a 10GB table which fits in a single DynamoDB shard, with no sharding. With the restriction of 1-5 operation per customer per second, this sounds like the ideal use case for DynamoDB.

What am I missing?



Amazon is limiting it to 5 operations per second per shard, not per customer. That is if you have 200 shards and 1000 write capacity.

It's a problem with how Amazon calculates your capacity units as it scales up Dynamo for you, if you have a particularly large data set with a few very active users.


The parent post is suggesting that 5 Million customers does not in any way imply 200 shards. It's much more likely that with 5M customers you have 1 or 2 shards. That's 4KB (one document) per customer.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: