No worries; your comment didn't seem like an attack at all! It raised interesting points, and the only reason I'm joining in here is because I think it's an interesting conversation.
I think the criticism you brought up is the most interesting one as well. The other tangents have been lurking in my mind for unrelated reasons (I read a fun short fiction yesterday about Google using its dorms to breed families, which is the only reason I brought it up), but I'd have understood their inclusion in this discussion as well. And it makes sense that the various criticisms as a whole come across way more negatively than this news seems to deserve.
I think the criticism you brought up is the most interesting one as well. The other tangents have been lurking in my mind for unrelated reasons (I read a fun short fiction yesterday about Google using its dorms to breed families, which is the only reason I brought it up), but I'd have understood their inclusion in this discussion as well. And it makes sense that the various criticisms as a whole come across way more negatively than this news seems to deserve.