Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Ideal socialism is voluntary, just like ideal free markets.

I wonder whether your axiomatic belief is that we should all have freedom? Therefore you love the idea of free markets? I wonder if some of your "free market" comments would be better written in terms of freedom rather than economics.

Game theory and evolutionary stable strategies show the issues of cooperation versus defection.

Voluntary cooperation fails because power is required to enforce fairness/contracts and then the powerful can defect. That is independent of socialism or free markets.

Also authoritarianism and socialism are different things, even if history shows correlation. Socialism is a deeply tarred word, with radical differences in meaning (approximately equal to communism for many, or democracy for others).

If authoritarianism is a stable outcome, then it can be an outcome of free markets too.

Re your other thread: calling China a free market seems extremely odd, and basing any argument on that 'fact' is even odder. Edit: perhaps "Socialism is coercive cooperation" is similarly nonsensical.



> Ideal socialism is voluntary

There have been 20,000+ voluntary socialist communes set up in the US. They all failed. Socialism requires forcible coercion.


Have you no sense of decency, sir, at long last?


Wait, we had socialism in the US?




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: