Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

> I guess I don't see how gentrification is a problem at all

Often it's how the situation got there in the first place. For example, in one suburb in my city a few landlords who owned apartments started renting to "undesirables" - illegal aliens, prostitutes and known drug dealers. This brought all kinds of problems because the area became known as a "safe haven" for petty criminals.

This drove down the market values of all the properties in the area, which is of course what these landlords wanted. After people started moving out they started purchasing properties and land all over the area and when they were comfortable enough with what they had, they enlisted the help of the police to evict the undesirables (and thereafter push up rent). With more properties under their belt, they had more say in the rate payers association, which meant they had more power to vote on things that worked in their favour rather than the original residents. I'm sure you can see where things went from there.

The other side of things is also what gentrification usually implies - destruction of communities. But let's leave that for another discussion...



You are saying that the presence of low income housing causes its own destruction? Then how will low-income folks ever find housing?


I'm not saying that at all. I'm stating a real-world scenario that can lead to gentrification.

- Unscrupulous landlords intentionally drive down the price of property (this is NOT "low-income housing")

- They purchase the under-valued properties in bulk

- They increase rentals, prices and use power gained from the rate-payers association to force poorer people out, and to make it harder for them to move in

Furthermore, you can live on an expensive property and not be wealthy. That's not the same as buying a cheap property. Case-in-point: Families that have lived on the outer-skirts of a growing city for several generations. When they moved in the properties were relatively cheap, and rent was low. As the city grew, the land value increased. This does not automatically make them wealthy, and the increased prices does not automatically mean they will want to sell their properties or move out.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: