Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

I'm confused, are you asking if you should be fighting patent trolls or patents? If trolls, then fighting them is better than not. Patents are tools, valid and legal, you don't fight tools, you use them, improve them, complain about them, etc.


I'm talking about patents. Patents are tools in the same sense that landmines are.


Why choose the word landmine? What's wrong with, say, a hammer?


Hammers aren't used to exclude people from a path they might otherwise blissfully follow.


You simply aren't using enough hammers!

Though seriously, I think the term landmine is loaded toward using patents exclusively as a troll. A wider analogy could be like a toll bridge, where the builder should be compensated by travelers. Some tolls could be usurious, but that wouldn't invalidate the whole principle.


I guess I disagree with the idea that patents are inherently bad. Like hammers they can be used to build or to destroy.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: